Friday, April 13, 2012

Someday I'll figure out how to teach circles

Oh, circles.  How can I do you justice?

Circles present a dilemma for me.  I think it's because the way I typically introduce the standard equation of a circle is so abstract for something that is rather straight-forward.

The way I see most textbooks present circles, and the way I've presented circles in the past is very similar to this:


Aye aye aye.

Every semester I think, "Maybe I can make this derivation make sense to them this time around!"

And every semester I fail.  Miserably.  I mean, you can practically taste the glazed-over looks.  It doesn't matter how many times I say, "It's just the Pythagorean Theorem, guys!"  I've lost them.

So, I tried something different this time around.  It's still far from perfect, but the equation of a circle came much faster and from many more mouths than usual.  I did what most of us probably do when trying to verify a general concept:  apply it to a specific example.

I showed them this picture and asked them to relate the lengths of a, b, and r using the Pythagorean Theorem, and then find the exact lengths of a and b.  And, most importantly, how did they arrive at the lengths for a and b (without just counting units).

Then I showed them the same picture as before and asked for the same information, but this time--no grid, no numbers.  I told them to call the center (h,k) and the other point, which represents any point on the circle, (x,y).

They came to the result pretty quickly.

Some concerns I have with this strategy:  Do they understand the significance of x and y?  Did they just regurgitate the example from before without thinking about the fact that they're deriving a general equation? I desperately want to teach my students how to think abstractly and generally because, well, that's what pure mathematics is about.  But is it more important for some ideas than others?

Like I said, I'm happier with how things went this time around.  But not yet satisfied (hopefully I never fully will be).  Any suggestions are gladly welcomed!

1 comment:

  1. Students are very Anxious to know more Details About and for Rajasthan Question Paper 2022 for 10th Class so That they can Score Good marks in the Board Examination, Students are Left with Only a few days to Prepare and Revise All RBSE Secondary (Main) Exam Subjects before the Exam 2022 At This Time, For more Detailed Information about the Rajasthan Model Paper 2022 for 10th Class, go Through the below Article and Download it Pdf Format. RBSE Model Paper for 10th Students Can Download Pdf Format RBSE 10th Previous Question Paper 2022 for Hindi, English Medium All Subjects Maths, Science, Social Science, English and Hindi etc, Students can easily Download the Rajasthan Question Paper 2022 for Secondary (Main) Exam Them in PDF format, It will help them to Analyze the 30% Deleted Exam Pattern.


Tell me what you think!